Despite all the talk and the change
programs, empowerment is still mostly an illusion.
EMPOWERMENT:
THE EMPEROR’S NEW CLOTHES
BY CHRIS
ARGYRIS
Considering its
much touted potential, it’s no wonder that empowerment receives all the
attention it does. Who wouldn’t want more highly motivated employees to help
scale the twenty-first century? As one CEO has said, “No vision, no strategy
can be achieved without able and empowered employees.”
Top-level executives accept their responsibilities to
try to develop empowered employees. Human resource professionals devise
impressive theories of internal motivation. Experts teach change management.
Executives themselves launch any number of programs from reengineering to
continuous improvement to TQM. But little of it works.1
Take reengineering for instance. Although the rhetoric
of reengineering is consistent with empowerment, in reality it is anything but
that. Both research and practice indicate that the best results of
reengineering occur when jobs are rigorously specified and not when individuals
are left to define them. Even the GE workout sessions had their greatest
success when the problems resolved were relatively routine. Reengineering has
led to improvements in performance, but it has not produced the number of
highly motivated employees needed to ensure consistently high-performing organizations.
Few executives would deny that there has been little
growth in empowerment over the last 30 years. But why that is so remains a
riddle. The answer is complex. The change programs and practices we employ are
full of inner contradictions that cripple innovation, motivation, and drive. At
the same time, CEOs subtly undermine empowerment. Managers love empowerment in
theory, but the command-and-control model is what they trust and know best. For
their part, employees are often ambivalent about empowerment - it is great as
long as they are not held personally accountable. Even the change professionals
often stifle empowerment. Thus, despite all the best efforts that have gone
into fostering empowerment, it remains very much like the emperor’s new
clothes: we praise it loudly in public and ask ourselves privately why we can’t
see it. There has been no transformation in the workforce, and there has been
no sweeping metamorphosis.
Two
Kinds of Commitment
To understand why there has been no transformation,
we need to begin with commitment. Commitment is not simply a human relations
concept. It is an idea that is fundamental to our thinking about economics,
strategy, financial governance, information technology, and operations.
Commitment is about generating human energy and activating the human mind.
Without it, the implementation of any new initiative or idea would be seriously
compromised. Human beings can commit themselves in two fundamentally different
ways: externally and internally. Both are valuable in the workplace, but only
internal commitment reinforces empowerment. (See the exhibit “How Commitment
Differs.”)
External commitment - think of it as contractual compliance - is what an
organization gets when workers have little control over their destinies. It is
a fundamental truth of human nature and psychology that the less power people
have to shape their lives, the less commitment they will have. When, for example,
management single-handedly defines work conditions for employees, the employees
will almost certainly be externally committed. That commitment is external
because all that is left for employees is to do what is expected of them. The employees
will not feel responsible for the way the situation itself is defined. How can
they? They did not do the defining.
HOW
COMMITMENT DIFFERS
|
|
External Commitment
Tasks are defined by others.
|
Internal Commitment
Individuals define tasks.
|
The behavior required to perform
tasks is defined by others.
|
Individuals define the behavior
Required to perform tasks.
|
Performance goals are
defined by management.
|
Management and individuals
jointly define performance
goals that are challenging
for the individual.
|
The importance of the goal
is defined by others.
|
Individuals define
the importance of the goal.
|
If management wants employees to take more
responsibility for their own destiny, it must encourage the development of internal
commitment. As the name implies, internal commitment comes largely from
within. Individuals are committed to a particular project, person, or program
based on their own reasons or motivations. By definition, internal commitment
is participatory and very closely allied with empowerment. The more that top
management wants internal commitment from its employees, the more it must try
to involve employees in defining work objectives, specifying how to achieve
them, and setting stretch targets.
We might well ask whether everyone must participate
in order for empowerment to exist in an organization. In principle, the answer
is “yes”; in reality, there is a “but.” It is unrealistic to expect management
to allow thousands of employees to participate fully in self-governance. The
degree to which internal commitment is plausible in any organization is
certainly limited. Moreover, the extent of participation in corporate goals and
aspirations will vary with each employee’s wishes and intentions.
At SmithKline Beecham, in one of the most far-reaching
programs for employee participation that I know of, management used a merger as
an opportunity to build empowerment. Throughout the entire organization, more
than 400 task forces were created. Yet to this day top management does not
believe that internal commitment has been generated throughout the entire
company. Their realistic assessment is that not even all the employees on the
task forces feel empowered.
To be fair, it is important to remember that
empowerment is a goal that organizations approximate but never quite reach. The
fact is that it is possible to have various levels of commitment in an
organization and still get the job done. Curiously, employees have no trouble
understanding the need to keep within bounds. In all my work, I have yet to
find employees who make unrealistic demands about empowerment. For top
management, then, the essential thing to know is that there are limits to
internal commitment. Employees do not understand - in fact, they usually
resent - executives preaching internal commitment while continuing to demand
external commitment from the rank and file. Indeed, a great source of
discontent in organizations is that top-level managers continually risk their
credibility by espousing empowerment too glibly.
Clearly, if it is internal commitment that provides
the kind of outcomes that CEOs say they want, then they must be realistic and
judicious in their demands for it. But the problem goes deeper because the
framework that most organizations are now using to transform themselves
discourages employees from actually taking responsibility in their jobs.
Change Programs Increase Inner Contradictions
Major change programs are rife with inner contradictions.
By this, I mean that even when these programs and policies are implemented
correctly, they do not - and cannot - foster the behavior they are meant to
inspire. If the inner contradictions are brought to the surface and addressed,
they can be dealt with successfully; that is, they will not inhibit the kind of
personal commitment that management says it wants. But if the contradictions remain
buried and unacknowledged, as they usually do, they become a destructive force.
Not only do they stifle the development of empowerment, they also sap the
organization’s efficiency by breeding frustration and mistrust.
To illustrate, consider the advice that currently
represents best practice for implementing and promoting organizational change.
That advice breaks the process down into four basic steps:
•
Define a vision.
•
Define a competitive strategy consistent with the vision.
• Define
organizational work processes that, when executed, will implement the
strategy.
• Define
individual job requirements so that employees can carry out the
processes effectively.
The underlying pattern of these
instructions is consistent with what change researchers and practitioners have
learned about effective implementation over the years. Start with a clear
framework - a vision - and progressively make it operational so that it will
come alive. So that no one will have any doubts about how to align the four
parts of the process, management is advised to speak with one voice. This
process makes sense. It is rational.
Yet the process is so riddled with inner
contradictions that change programs that follow it will only end up creating
confusion, particularly at the implementation stage. Given that all the steps
have been so precisely described through a set of instructions, the advice
actually encourages more external than internal commitment. Clearly, when
employees’ actions are defined almost exclusively from the outside (as they are
in most change programs), the resulting behavior cannot be empowering and
liberating. One immediate consequence is that employees react to the change program
by quietly distancing themselves from it. Thus the change program is successful
in terms of improving performance because it helps reduce mistakes, as in the
case of TQM, or because it helps employees embrace best practices. But at the
same time, it undermines internal commitment. In short, the advice for
implementing change simply does not provide the new source of energy that many
executives want.
But the real danger is that change programs end up
poisoning the entire corporation with long-lasting mixed messages. Internally
committed employees interpret these messages as “do your own thing - the way
we tell you.” They reluctantly toe the line. Employees who prefer external
commitment will also pick up the mixed messages; however, these people will be
relieved because they feel protected from having to take any personal responsibility.
In this way, the very working habits that executives do not want to see
continued in their organizations are strengthened and reinforced. The result is
invariably more inner contradictions and more inefficiency and cynicism, all of
which get in the way of real change.
CEOs Undermine Empowerment
CEOs work against empowerment both consciously and
unconsciously. Surprisingly - at least to outsiders - executives do not always
seem to want what they say they need. Consider a few typical remarks that I
came across during my research. These remarks - excerpted from a roundtable
discussion of executives from world-class companies - indicate very clearly
the ambivalence of CEOs toward internal commitment and empowerment. The first
CEO noted that with “well-defined processes where the variances are small and
the operating limits are well defined,” you no longer need the old
command-and-control approach. Workers are now empowered, “provided they respect
the process,” he said. The second CEO agreed that these “processes are
liberating,” while the third observed that many employees have a tough time
understanding what it means for processes to be “reliable, respectable, and
in control.”
Let us stop a moment and ask ourselves how there can
be empowerment when there is neither guesswork nor challenges - when the job
requirements are predetermined and the processes are controlled. For employees
operating in such a world, the environment is not empowering; it is foolproof. This
is not a milieu in which individuals can aspire to self-governance. On the
contrary, as long as they buy in and follow the dictates of the processes, the
employees in the companies just described will only become more externally
motivated.
The enthusiastic use of champions in virtually all
contemporary change programs sends a similar mixed message from CEOs to
employees. Top management is well aware of the dangers of piecemeal
implementation and eventual fade-out in major change programs. They strive to
overcome those problems by anointing champions. The champions pursue
performance objectives with tenacity, managing by decree. They have generous
resources available to ensure compliance, and they monitor employees’ progress
frequently. Altogether, these behaviors reinforce the top-down control features
of the external commitment model. The single voice of fervent champions leads
employees to feel that management is in control, and it drives out the sense of
internal responsibility and personal empowerment. How can employees feel
empowered if someone is always “selling” them or controlling them from the top
down? Indeed, such champions would not be necessary if employees were
internally committed. The result of all these interventions is disarray.
Managers and the change programs they use undermine the empowerment they so
desperately want to achieve. Why does this occur? Could it be that today’s
top-level managers don’t truly want empowered employees? In truth, they are probably
unsure. At the same time, employees do not hold executives to task for their
behavior. Employees have their own mixed feelings about empowerment.
Employees
Have Their Doubts
External commitment is a psychological survival
mechanism for many employees - it is a form of adaptive behavior that allows
individuals to get by in most work environments. How that survival mechanism
works is illustrated quite dramatically today in the former East Germany.
When the Berlin Wall came down, a routine way of life
for East German workers came to an end. Most workers had learned to survive by
complying. For 40 years, most plants were run in accordance with the dictates
of central planners. If many East Germans had pushed for greater control over
their destinies, their lives might have been endangered. As a result, East
German workers over the years learned to define performance as doing the
minimum of what was required of them.
After the fall of communism, I participated in many
discussions with West German executives who were surprised and baffled by the
lack of initiative and aspiration displayed by the East Germans. What those
executives failed to understand is how bewildering - indeed, how threatening it
can be for people to take internal commitment seriously, especially those who
have lived their entire lives by the rules of external commitment. As I
listened to the West German executives who wanted to make East German employees
more internally committed, I thought of several cases in the United States and
elsewhere where similar problems exist. Again and again in my experience,
prolonged external commitment made internal commitment extremely unlikely,
because a sense of empowerment is not innate. It is something that must be
learned, developed, and honed.
The question, then, is, How do you
produce internal commitment? One thing for sure is that the incentive programs
executives have used - for instance, higher compensation, better career paths,
“employee of the month” recognition awards - simply do not work. On the
contrary, in all my years as a change consultant, I have repeatedly witnessed
how offering employees the “right” rewards creates dependency rather than
empowerment. Inevitably, the power of such methods wears off with use, and all
that has been created is more external commitment.
Consider one company with substantial
financial woes. In that case, the CEO decided at considerable personal
sacrifice to raise his employees’ salaries. But his own research later showed
that the employees merely considered their raises to be in keeping with their
equity in the labor market. Internal commitment had not increased. Employees
continued to do only what was asked of them as long as the rewards were
increased. They followed the rules, but they did not take any initiative. They
did not take risks, nor did they show the sense of personal responsibility that
management sought. The CEO was surprised, but I thought that these results were
entirely predictable for two reasons. First, pay, like other popular incentive schemes,
often advances external commitment while creating a bias against internal
commitment. Second, and more fundamental, many employees do not embrace the
idea of empowerment with any more gusto than management does. For a lot of
people, empowerment is just too much work. Like the workers in East Germany,
almost all employees have learned to survive by depending on external
commitment.
When it comes to empowerment, executives
and employees are engaged in shadowboxing. Management says it wants employees
who participate more; employees say they want to be more involved. But it is
difficult to know who means what. Is it just a charade? Employees push for
greater autonomy; management says the right thing but tries to keep control
through information systems, processes, and tools. Employees see vestiges of
the old command-and-control model as confirming their worse suspicions - that
superiors want unchallenged power. Management just wants to see better
numbers. Thus the battle between autonomy and control rages on, and meanwhile,
as companies make the transition into the next century, the potential for real
empowerment is squandered.
Change Professionals Inhibit Empowerment
During the past decade, I have had the opportunity to
work with more than 300 change experts in different organizations. Such
individuals differ in their practices and their effectiveness, of course, but
more striking than the differences are the patterns that recur.
Caught in the middle of the battle
between autonomy and control, the change professional has a tough assignment.
The role of the change professional, whether internal or external, is
ostensibly to facilitate organizational change and continuous learning. In
their own way, however, the vast majority of change professionals actually
inhibit empowerment in organizations.
To understand how that occurs, consider
what happens as Tom, a change agent, tries to work with Jack, a line manager.
(Both are composite figures typical of those I encountered in my research.)
Jack is told by his boss to work with Tom, who is there to “help” Jack empower
his organization. The change program begins with a series of meetings and
discussions. Tom talks passionately about openness, honesty, and trust as the
foundations of empowerment. Many employees leave these meetings feeling
hopeful about the direction that the company is taking toward more open
communication. A month into the program, however, Tom observes that Jack has
fallen back into his old style of management. He decides that he had better confront
Jack:
Tom’s
unspoken thoughts:
tom: Things
aren’t going well.
tom: Oh
great. All Jack cares about is the numbers. Empowerment isn’t even on his
agenda.
tom: Just
what I feared. Jack’s not “walking the talk.” He just doesn’t get it at all.
tom: This is hopeless! There’s got to be an easier way
to make a living. I’11 never get through to him. I wish I could tell Jack
what I think, but I don’t want to put him on the defensive. I’ve got to stay
cool.
|
What
Tom and Jack say:
tom: So how’s
everything going?
jack: Things
are going pretty well. There’s a lot of pressure from above, but we’re
meeting the numbers.
tom: Great.
Super. But I was also wondering how well we’re doing at getting people more
committed to their jobs. How empowered do you think people feel?
jack: Well, I
think we’re doing okay. If there are problems, people come to me and we work
it out. Sure, some people are never satisfied. But that’s just a few people,
and we can handle them.
tom: Look,
Jack, if you solve all their problems, how are we going to empower our employees?
jack: Well, to
be honest with you, Tom, the signal I’m getting from above is that my job is
to produce the numbers without, you know, upsetting people. To be fair, I think
I’m doing that.
|
What’s happening here? The change program that began
with great enthusiasm is clearly in deep trouble. It’s a pattern I’ve observed
over and over again. After the initial excitement passes, reality inevitably
settles in. Put aside the nice rhetoric of empowerment, employees will
have problems. They will ask their managers for help, and their managers
will tell them what to do. That is how most work gets done and how
organizations meet their numbers. And in many cases, there’s absolutely nothing
wrong with this, except that it goes against the theory of empowerment.
What does Tom do when he observes Jack telling his
employees what to do? Instead of figuring out whether Jack is doing the right
thing in this situation, change experts like Tom will almost always be
dismayed, because the managers aren’t walking the talk of empowerment. Rarely
have I seen a change professional help a manager deal effectively with being
caught between a rock and a hard place. Even more uncommon is a change agent
who offers practical advice to the manager about what to do.
Not only is Tom unwilling to acknowledge the real
problem Jack is having, but he papers over his own thoughts. He tries to act as
if he still believes the program can be successful when, in fact, he has given
up hope. Tom himself is guilty of not walking the talk of openness, honesty,
and trust.
In my experience, line managers are far more willing
to acknowledge the inner contradictions of change programs - at least, in
private. They will admit to distancing themselves from the soft stuff - two-way
participation, internal commitment, and discontinuous thinking - to focus
instead on the numbers. Managers like Jack often conclude rightly, I’m afraid -
that the change agent does not know how to help them. So Jack listens politely
as Tom warns him about the dangers of backsliding and exhorts him to be more
persistent. And then Jack goes on about his business.
In the end, everyone is frustrated. In theory, empowerment
should make it easier for organizations to meet their numbers. But when change
programs are imposed without recognizing the limitations of empowerment and
when managers and employees are not helped to deal effectively and openly with
them, the organization ends up worse off than it was to begin with. Empowerment
too often enters the realm of political correctness, which means that no one
can say what he or she is thinking: this is just nonsense. In this scenario, if
you challenge the change agent, you become an enemy of change.
So instead of feeling more empowered, people
throughout the organization feel more trapped and less able to talk openly
about what’s really going on. Is it any wonder that change programs don’t
succeed and that they actually undermine the credibility of top management?
What
Is to Be Done?
Despite
all the rhetoric surrounding transformation and major change programs, the
reality is that today’s managers have not yet encountered change programs that
work. As we have seen, the reasons for that are complex. Although managers
share some of the responsibility for undermining internal motivation in their
organizations, the change programs that could create high levels of internal
commitment and empowerment in corporations do not yet exist. That is why I
believe it is time to begin the research and experimentation that is required
to find some viable answers. But for now, let me begin with some
recommendations that may help executives think more sensibly about
empowerment.
•
Recognize that every company has both top-down controls and programs that
empower people, and that some inconsistencies are inevitable and must simply be
managed. When these inner contradictions become apparent, encourage
individuals to bring them to the surface; otherwise, a credibility gap will be
created that can pollute the organization for many years to come.
•
Don’t undertake blatantly contradictory programs. For instance, stop creating
change programs that are intended to expand internal commitment but are
designed in ways that produce external commitment. Make sure that what is being
espoused will not contradict what actually happens.
•
Understand that empowerment has its limits. Know how much can be created and
what can be accomplished. Know that empowerment is not a cure-all. Do not evoke
it needlessly. Once it has been created, do not misuse it. Be clear about who
has the right to change things. Specify the likely limits of permissible
change.
•
Realize that external and internal commitment can coexist in organizations but
that how they do so is crucial to the ultimate success or failure of
empowerment in the organization. For instance, external commitment is all it
takes for performance in most routine jobs. Unnecessary attempts to increase
empowerment only end up creating downward spirals of cynicism, disillusionment,
and inefficiencies. As a first precaution, distinguish between jobs that
require internal commitment and those that do not.
• Establish working conditions to increase empowerment
in the organization. If you want to help individuals move away from external
commitment, encourage them to examine their own behavior. It has been my
experience that many employees are willing to become more personally committed
if management is really sincere, if the work allows it, and if the rewards
reinforce it.
•
Calculate factors such as morale, satisfaction, and even commitment into your
human relations policies, but do not make them the ultimate criteria. They are
penultimate. The ultimate goal is performance. Individuals can be excellent
performers and report low morale, yet it is performance and not morale that is
paramount. When morale, satisfaction, and sense of empowerment are used as the
ultimate criteria for success in organizations, they cover up many of the
problems that organizations must overcome in the twenty-first century.
•
Help employees understand the choices they make about their own level of
commitment. One of the most helpful things we can do in organizations -
indeed, in life - is to require that human beings not knowingly kid themselves
about their effectiveness.
Finally, remember that empowerment can run contrary to
human nature, and be realistic about how to achieve and use it. To paraphrase
Abraham Lincoln: You can empower all of the people some of the time and some of
the people all of the time, but you can’t empower all of the people all of the
time. In the last analysis, nobody should expect more than that.
1. For a
description of the similarities and differences in employee-involvement,
reengineering, and TQM programs, see Susan Alberts Mohrman, J.R. Galbraith, and
Edward E. Alwair, Tomorrow’s Organization
(San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1998); J. Hendry, “Processing Reengineering and
the Dynamic Balance of the Organization,” European Management Journal,
vol. 13, no. I, pp. 51-57; T. Eccles, “The Deceptive Allure of Empowerment,” Long
Range Planning, vol. 26, no. 6, pp. 13-21; and B.G. Jackson, “Reengineering
the Sense of Self: The Managers and the Management Gurus,” Journal of
Management Studies, 1996, vol. 33, no.5, pp. 571-590.
Chris Argyris is the James Bryant Conant Professor
Emeritus of Education and Organizational Behavior at Harvard University in
Cambridge, Massachusetts. He is the author of “Good Communication That Blocks
Learning” (HBR July-August 1994), a McKinsey Award winner. He is also a
director at Monitor Company in Cambridge.
